As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links in this article may be affiliate links. How we choose gear
One owner on the Practical Golf forum bought a Gary Wiren bag for roughly $20 and says it was still in good shape ten years later, taking a few hundred hits a year. That is the upside of well-made golf impact bags in 2027, and the downside sits on the other side of the category: Golf Insider’s PGA-professional tester says cheaper bags tend to fail at the seams and handles.
An impact bag is a fillable bag you hit without a ball, so you can feel where your hands and the shaft sit at contact, in a garage or backyard and in any weather. This guide sorts six bags by build, feedback and the way each is meant to be hit, then covers the retractable golf impact screen that shoppers often meet in the same search results, since the two cost very different amounts and do very different jobs. The findings draw on buying guides, instructor write-ups, owner threads and maker pages, with no hands-on testing, and several of those sources date from 2023 or earlier.
Seams, fill and slope: what separates one impact bag from another
Material comes first. BestReviews says most bags are heavy waterproof vinyl, which suits wet grass but should not live outside, while canvas gives more feel and wears out sooner. EyeLine uses ballistic nylon for its cube. Size matters less than people assume: the same guide puts typical bags at 15 to 18 inches across and 10 to 12 inches tall, with smaller ones feeling too light and larger ones too heavy.
Seam placement is the detail most listings skip. BestReviews prefers a zipper or Velcro seam across the top and warns that a seam running around the top circumference can be struck by the club and damaged. Fill is the other lever: soft cloth such as old towels, T-shirts or pillows, never sand or gravel, and the bag should slide only a few inches per strike, so add fill if it travels more than a foot. A site administrator in a Sand Trap forum thread gave the same advice, socks or old cloth over sand, and Think Indoor suggests stopping at 70 to 80 percent full.
Price barely separates the tiers. BestReviews puts low-cost bags at $15 to $25, most bags at $20 to $40, and says anything over $40 may bundle a second training aid.
| Model | Outer material | Size where stated | Feedback features | Anchor point | Price signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Gary Wiren Impact Bag | Sturdy waterproof build | Not stated | Rounded, no slope, no target | Not stated | $45 to $55 |
| SKLZ Smash Bag | PVC and polypropylene | Not stated | Printed target map | Stake loop | $35 to $40 |
| EyeLine Golf Impact Cube | Ballistic nylon | Not stated (about 10 lb filled) | Four angled faces | Not stated | $60 to $75 |
| Partage Smash Bag | Waterproof PVC | 16.5 by 16.5 by 9.5 in | Buckle for stability | Not stated | Check the current price on Amazon.com |
| GoSports Golf Swing Bag | Heavy canvas | About 15.5 by 9.5 in filled | Drills included | Not stated | Under $25 |
| Intech Golf Swing Impact Bag | Not stated | Not stated | None noted | Anchor clip | Check the current price on Amazon.com |
Only the EyeLine Golf Impact Cube changes the angle of attack by face, and only the SKLZ Smash Bag tells you how the bag sat after the hit. The cube costs roughly $20 to $40 more than the SKLZ bag (my arithmetic from the ranges above), which is the whole price gap between “a bag” and “a bag with a design idea.”
Browse the current listings on Amazon.com before you commit to a fill plan.
The best golf impact bags, matched to six practice habits
Each entry starts from a habit or a constraint, because the sources agree that the bags differ more in durability and feel than in what they teach.
1. Dr. Gary Wiren Impact Bag — plain, sturdy, proven over time
Rick Grayson, a PGA professional profiled by the Golf Range Association in 2014, has used this bag in lessons for more than 20 years and films students hitting it before and after swing changes. By his account most students show dramatic changes on video. Gary Wiren designed it, and Grayson counts him among the greatest professionals in PGA history.
The Dr. Gary Wiren Impact Bag is deliberately basic. Golf Insider’s tester describes a rounded shape with no slanted edges, which gives less firm resistance at the angle you want and makes forward shaft lean harder to create, yet calls it sturdy, long-lasting, about 90 percent as good as the Tour Striker and EyeLine bags and 30 to 50 percent cheaper. It ships unfilled, and the golf shop selling it advises old towels, blankets or clothes, with no sand or overly heavy fill.
Durability evidence is the strongest of the six, though not flawless. The forum owner above fills the bag with towels and clothing for roughly 6 pounds. BestReviews names it best of the bunch yet flags the zipper as a weak point and warns it is very loud, and a syndicated version of that guide says too many all-out hits can split the seams. Expect to read feedback with your own eyes, since there is no target map.
2. SKLZ Smash Bag — target map and stake loop included
Between $35 and $40 at the maker’s distributor and two retailers, the SKLZ Smash Bag is the budget route to a printed target map. The maker says that after a swing you check the map’s angle, and if the strike was true the bag stays aligned. The distributor page lists a zipper, a loop for staking it down (BestReviews calls it a grommet near the bottom) and a material of 95 percent PVC and 5 percent polypropylene, aimed at beginner and intermediate golfers.
Think Indoor says overfilling dulls the feedback, so aim for 70 to 80 percent full. BestReviews adds that slower, smoother swings suit the bag.
Pros:
- ✅ Printed target map shows how the bag sat after impact, per the maker
- ✅ Zipper fill and a stake loop for outdoor use
- ✅ One of the cheaper bags in this group
Cons:
- ❌ BestReviews says the seams split relatively easily
- ❌ Buyer reviews copied onto Desertcart storefront pages split between happy owners and people whose seams opened within days or weeks
- ❌ Warranty length differs by page: one year on the distributor’s page, 90 days limited at Academy
3. EyeLine Golf Impact Cube — four angled faces, four clubs
Wedge, 7-iron and driver each get their own face on the EyeLine Golf Impact Cube, which is the reason to pay more. A retailer page lists four sides and four impact positions: a slanted wedge-lean side, a 7-iron lean and a vertical driver side. EyeLine suggests filling it with towels or old linen to about 10 pounds, and the same retailer quotes Ed Bowe, director of instruction at Amelia Island, saying he uses it in every lesson.
Golf Insider’s tester ranks it near the top, calls it very durable, praises the clean edges for swing-path drills and keeps it off the number one spot only because of cost. Maker and retailer pages now sell an Impact Cube 2.0, while the Golf Insider and Think Indoor write-ups predate that label. A product page on the Shop app shows 4.1 out of 5 from 35 ratings for the 2.0, a small sample.
Prices run between about $60 and $75 across the maker’s range and two golf shops. EyeLine’s own pages promise a 60-day improvement guarantee, and whether that carries over to an Amazon order is not stated.
Pros:
- ✅ Different lean angles for wedge, mid-iron and driver
- ✅ Ballistic nylon, described as very durable by Golf Insider
- ✅ Clean edges suit path-constraint drills
Cons:
- ❌ Top of the price range, per Golf Insider
- ❌ Think Indoor lists louder impact as a drawback
See the cube’s current options on Amazon.com.
4. Partage Smash Bag — a lower-cost bag with split reviews
Seams giving way and handles falling off are the usual complaints about cheaper bags, according to Golf Insider’s tester, who says the Partage Smash Bag fares better than most in its price range based on buyer reviews. Golf Circuit calls Partage among the best middle-tier smash bags for newcomers on a budget, and a syndicated BestReviews article lists it as worth checking out.
A Desertcart storefront page lists waterproof PVC, a buckle for stability, 16.5 by 16.5 by 9.5 inches and a one-year satisfaction guarantee. Buyer reviews on that page disagree: one golfer with an 82 mph 7-iron swing calls it sturdy, while another says it was not sturdy enough. Neither review says how hard the bag was hit, so swing effort is the unknown.
Those 16.5 inches sit inside the 15-to-18-inch range BestReviews calls typical.
5. GoSports Golf Swing Bag — canvas feel with drills included
Heavy canvas gives the GoSports Golf Swing Bag a different feel from the vinyl bags above, and BestReviews explains the trade: canvas has more give but lasts less long and is not waterproof. GoSports’ own store lists it at under $25, about 15.5 by 9.5 inches once filled, with instructional drills in the box and a US design.
Think Indoor credits one-piece construction with fewer weak points and calls the bag water-resistant, which sits awkwardly beside BestReviews’ point about canvas, so keep it off wet ground. The same review says it may tip on hard hits and that aggressive driver practice may need extra weight at the base.
Pros:
- ✅ Drills come with the bag, per the maker
- ✅ Canvas feel, with fewer seams to fail per Think Indoor
- ✅ Among the lowest prices in the group
Cons:
- ❌ No target map
- ❌ May tip on hard hits, per Think Indoor
- ❌ Canvas is not waterproof, per BestReviews
6. Intech Golf Swing Impact Bag — anchor clip for small spaces
Small garages and spare rooms are where BestReviews files the Intech Golf Swing Impact Bag, crediting an anchor clip that secures it. The guide says to fill it with towels, clothes or sheets, calls it sturdy, and also calls it very loud, advising outdoor use or ear protection indoors. The SKLZ stake loop and this clip are the two anchoring details noted among the six.
Noise is a recurring theme. A forum owner on the Practical Golf thread says a cheap Amazon bag with a plastic finish was very loud, and BestReviews calls the Wiren bag very loud as well. BestReviews’ general advice applies here too: make sure you have room for your backswing indoors.
Golf Insider ranks the Tour Striker Smart Bag first for its sloped edges that encourage forward shaft lean and a detachable plane board, at $15 to $20 more than a standard bag. No Amazon.com listing for it turned up, so it sits outside the six.
Golf impact bags reviews: where owners and testers agree, and where they split
Seams, zippers and handles fail first, and three independent kinds of source say so. Golf Insider’s tester names seams and handles on cheaper bags, BestReviews flags the zipper on the Dr. Gary Wiren Impact Bag and seams on the SKLZ Smash Bag and the Amazingli Golf Impact Power Smash Bag, and buyer reviews on Desertcart pages for the SKLZ bag describe stitching coming apart after days or weeks. That is a consensus, though one aimed at the cheaper bags more than the premium ones.
Soft fill is the second agreement. BestReviews, the Sand Trap administrator and a listing for the Amazingli bag all say no sand, and one SKLZ buyer on the Desertcart page puts a sandbag on the impact side anyway, so the point is not unanimous.
The splits are more useful. Golfer Logic says smash bags are typically built for irons and wedges only, while the EyeLine Golf Impact Cube has a driver face. Swing effort divides opinion too: one SKLZ buyer says they swing at full speed in the backyard, and BestReviews, Golf Insider and a GOLF.com write-up all advise controlled swings, GOLF.com putting the target at about 70 percent effort.
Think Indoor lists the ASENVER Silent Golf Impact Bag for noise-sensitive homes. It is mesh, may slide on hard floors and has no fill window, so a mat is advised. BestReviews’ text is dated March 2023, so bundles and designs may have changed.
Are golf impact bags good? What instructors and buyers report
For one job, yes: feeling impact position without a ball. GOLF.com’s training-aid roundup calls the impact bag an instructor favorite partly because it is so simple, and Grayson uses it daily in lessons. Golf Insider’s tester calls the tool a great way to improve ball striking, then draws two limits. Impact bags are not an effective or safe way to raise clubhead speed, and unrestrained hitting carries a tendonitis risk, so he advises checking with a PGA professional or qualified trainer first.
A syndicated BestReviews article adds the missing piece: the biggest weakness is that with no ball there is nothing to track for accuracy, yet it beats skipping practice on a rainy day. Buyers on the Desertcart pages split the same way. One says transferring the bag’s feel to a real ball is challenging, another finds it no magic fix but a proven way to improve impact position, and a forum owner on Practical Golf uses one for about ten minutes a day in limited space.
Golf Insider’s drills give a sensible start:
- Address to impact: set the bag against a wall, press into it with a mid-iron without a backswing, three to six reps, then two more sets.
- Push through impact: press in, then slide the bag along the floor with about 6 feet of clear space, driving from the trunk while the wrists hold firm.
- Short swing: take the club back about 6 inches, drive into the bag and push it through, lengthening the swing slowly.
Retractable golf impact screens: a different budget for a different job
A bag takes the hit in place of a ball, while a retractable screen catches real shots for a projector or launch monitor. The cost gap shows it: the bags above run from about $20 to $75, and the Elite Screens GolfSim Electric listed around $900 to $940 for the 10-by-7-foot size at two retailers and about $1,760 for the 13-foot-wide one. One custom Gungho Golf screen was listed above $4,000.
What a retractable golf impact screen asks of your room
Golfers Authority calls a retractable screen worth buying for limited space and year-round practice, and its numbers come with a warning: the article says 9 to 10 feet of ceiling in one section and at least 10 feet in its FAQ. The roller takes about a foot, leaving roughly 9 feet of screen, with a footprint near 10 feet 6 inches wide and 12 feet deep and a stance at least 10 feet from the screen. It also says to mount into wood, concrete or metal beams, since drywall anchors are not adequate.
Canvas Etc rates retractables mid-range on price and durability, names the retraction mechanism as a potential failure point and notes they are not portable. Indoor Golf Outlet warns that some models have aluminum piping at the bottom that one long-iron or driver strike could damage. Golfers Authority’s lifespan and accuracy figures come without sources, so treat them as seller-side claims.
Best retractable golf impact screen: the real options compared
Which is best depends on motorized versus manual and on your ceiling. Elite Screens’ GolfSim Electric page gives the most checkable detail: the Elite Screens GolfSim Electric uses ImpactWhite 250 material rated for ball speeds up to 155 mph, a steel housing with brackets, an RF remote and a 2-year limited warranty. It sells no repair kits for the material and excludes damage from scuffed balls. Best Buy’s page labels the 10-foot model 10 feet high by 7 feet wide, while Elite’s own store header reads differently, so confirm the size before ordering.
The SportScreen Vanish Series is a roll-up studio system that Austad’s calls the first of its kind, with a three-ply impact screen on a UK retailer’s page. The maker’s blog describes it as manual, and a Vanish Lite variant pairs a retractable front screen with side curtains on a track. The G-Trak Retractable Golf Simulator Impact Screen was listed near $2,000 and out of stock at Austad’s. Elite’s page points buyers to its own store and authorized dealers and never mentions Amazon, so check whether Amazon.com carries the exact model.
Fill, drivers, noise and swing speed: quick answers
❓ What should you fill a golf impact bag with?
❓ Can you hit a golf impact bag with a driver?
❓ Will an impact bag add clubhead speed?
❓ How loud is a golf impact bag indoors?
❓ Do you need a retractable golf impact screen to use an impact bag?
Which impact bag to buy first
Start with the build, not the printed target. For most buyers of golf impact bags, the Dr. Gary Wiren Impact Bag is the safest first purchase: a PGA instructor and a ten-year forum owner vouch for it, and it costs well under the cube. Add the SKLZ Smash Bag if a target map matters to you, accepting that its seams drew repeated complaints, or step up to the EyeLine Golf Impact Cube when you want separate faces for wedge, mid-iron and driver lean. Whichever you take, fill it with soft cloth, swing at about 70 percent effort and keep it dry. Leave retractable screens for a garage with a 10-foot ceiling and a budget near $900 or more.
Open the Amazon.com listings for the two or three bags you are weighing.
Recommended for You
- Graphite design golf shafts: Which One Fits Your Swing?
- Golf cart bags: Which One Fits How You Ride?
- Golf cart wraps: Which One Fits Your Cart?
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through these links, at no additional cost to you.
Set aside two old bath towels before the bag arrives, and your first session can start the same afternoon.





